Manufacturing

Supply Chain Resilience: How to Future-Proof Your Supplier Network

By Abby Jenkins and Ian McCue for Brainyard
June 18, 2020
Ship top view

In short:

  • Resilience measures your company’s ability to quickly recognize, react to and recover from a disruption to your supplier network.
  • Effectively managing a supply chain in times of crisis requires preplanning, real-time information sources and the ability to make fast decisions based on that data.
  • There’s nothing like a pandemic to reveal supply chain vulnerabilities. Here are some (relatively) painless ways to make your end-to-end supplier network more robust.

Over the last few decades, supply chains have become … complicated. Globalization made intricate, interconnected supplier networks spanning multiple continents, time zones, currencies and languages the norm for most product-based organizations. While that brought cost savings, it also introduced risks that, as some companies learned the hard way, could send the business scrambling.

Supply chains have always faced the possibility of disruptions, from a mishap that impacts just one supplier — like a fire or broken water pipe — to sweeping events like major natural disasters, political and economic instability and other catastrophes. Depending on the nature of the disruption, it could affect one or many links in the chain, including supplier relationships and sourcing, procurement and purchasing, demand planning, manufacturing, inventory management, warehousing and transportation.

Does your company understand the potential risks that lurk within your supply chain? Have you planned for disruptions based on that risk profile?

If your company has not yet done this analysis, now is an opportune time because the coronavirus pandemic has likely laid bare any weak links. Finance teams need to be part of that process. Use that insight into the supplier network to identify areas of fragility or inefficiency and offer to help negotiate relationships with new, alternative business partners.

Those backup sources can keep operations alive and revenue flowing.

What is Supply Chain Resilience?

On a fundamental level, it’s a company’s ability to quickly recognize, react to and recover from a disruption. Contingency plans are a key building block of supply chain resilience, for example.

However, simply creating a plan and filing it away may lead to a false sense of security. For most product companies, the supplier network is constantly evolving. Your plan should likewise be updated regularly. That exercise includes assessments of business relationships with all current suppliers, a list of potential alternatives, a business analysis of your most critical suppliers based on SKUs and action plans listing what steps to take to keep production alive if any of those links broke.

We advise, at minimum, developing a risk management plan before the unexpected strikes. By creating a contingency plan for a variety of disruptive events, ops teams are empowered to respond quickly and, hopefully, reduce the impact and longevity of a disruption.

Even better, find a second source for at least first- and second-tier suppliers and then actively use those resources. Even if costs dictate a 90/10 situation, active relationships pay off, as we’ll discuss.

How Do You Build a Resilient Supply Chain?

Harvard Business Review notes that many companies lacked visibility into the impact the 2011 earthquake and tsunami in Fukushima, Japan, would have on lower-level suppliers, and they paid the price financially. No doubt the COVID-19 outbreak in China also caught many companies by surprise.

Every disruption is different and presents a unique set of risks. It’s impossible to map out every possible scenario, but by using supply chain mapping, you can plan for the most likely types of events and consider how each would affect operations.

Mapping can be as simple as using a free template; you can also use software tools to draw out interconnections. What’s important is to uncover the areas that will feel the biggest impact from each type of disruption. This stretches beyond knowing your Tier 1 and Tier 2 suppliers and manufacturers. Who are your suppliers’ suppliers? Where do your suppliers source their materials from?

Breaking down your supply chain to this extent is a lot of work, and it can be difficult to track all those upstream suppliers. But the effort will pay off many times over when there is a disruption.

A Practical Approach to Managing Sourcing Risk
Use revenue impact and risk of supply disruption to prioritize supply-chain-resiliency measures.
LOW RISK OF SUPPLY DISRUPTION HIGH RISK OF SUPPLY DISRUPTION
Two or more sources are qualified. Two or more sources are qualified, but all business is routed to one supplier. Alternate source is available but needs to be qualified before using. No alternate source is available or possible.
HIGH REVENUE IMPACT if supplier or part(s) is lost

Monitor suppliers 24/7.

Source from two suppliers (75%–25%) rather than one.

Map suppliers’ manufacturing, warehouse, and distribution sites to ensure they’re not all in the same region.

Identify the Tier 2 suppliers that Tier 1 suppliers use for critical parts or materials.

Buy insurance to cover profits lost from a disruptive event at critical suppliers’ sites.

Monitor suppliers 24/7.

Buy insurance to cover profits lost from a disruptive event at critical suppliers’ sites.

Work with sole-source suppliers to develop alternate source.

Know where suppliers build and store your parts and raw materials.

Ask sole-source suppliers to build and store parts at alternate sites.

Identify and monitor the sub-tier suppliers that your Tier 1 suppliers use for critical parts or materials.

Ensure Tier 1 suppliers have comprehensive risk management programs (i.e., they map and monitor their suppliers, adding alternate sources for their highest-risk suppliers).

LOW REVENUE IMPACT if supplier or part(s) is lost

Monitor suppliers for shifts that might increase their risk, such as a corporate restructuring, M&A, profit warning, lawsuits, etc.

Know where suppliers’ manufacturing and warehousing sites are located, and seek geographic diversity to avoid total loss of supply in future natural disasters.

Identify suppliers that rely on the same sub-tier suppliers for critical materials.

Monitor suppliers 24/7.

Know where suppliers build and store your parts and raw materials.

Identify sub-tier suppliers and sites.

Ask suppliers to build and store parts in multiple sites (particularly when an alternate supplier cannot be found).

Ensure Tier 1 suppliers have comprehensive risk management programs (i.e., they map and monitor their suppliers, adding alternate sources for their highest-risk suppliers).

Source: Resilic

Let’s walk through seven areas of the supply chain impacted by risk and explain how you can increase your resilience:

Sourcing relationships: Increasing the resilience of this foundational link in the supply chain starts with strengthening relationships with current suppliers. Companies should view this as a partnership that benefits both parties and communicate that they recognize the value of each supplier.

Maintaining solid relationships with partners should earn you more flexibility when there’s a disruption and a supplier suddenly sees overwhelming demand for its products. A timely example: face mask and medical glove manufacturers saw demand for their products spike as the coronavirus spread across the globe. In most cases, the distributors and retailers that had worked with these suppliers for years received first priority and could get these items at a fair price.

Redundancy: Supplier-side redundancy is a crucial element of supply chain resilience. Businesses should document the capabilities of all current partners. One supplier could have several facilities spread across multiple countries and be equipped to shift its operations in response to a disruption. Or, maybe it could, with some notice, revamp its manufacturing to make related materials. Ask existing suppliers for documentation on the scale of their operations and their capacity to shift production, both geographically and materially. Suspect embellishment? Get references, talk to companies that use the supplier and ask them to confirm the numbers given to you.

While you may have preferred suppliers, it’s risky to depend solely on one partner to keep your supply chain operational. You need relationships with a number of suppliers that can produce the same or a similar product as the primary one, especially for top SKUs. These suppliers should be spread out geographically, because some disruptions will affect entire countries or regions.

Have a plan to vet backup suppliers on a regular basis, making sure they remain capable of supplying the necessary parts or materials and ramping up production, if necessary. It’s important to note that finding, vetting and onboarding suppliers takes time, and most have long lead times. The period between purchase order and delivery for products coming to the United States from China is usually five to nine months. Given trade tensions and the ongoing effects of COVID-19, it could take longer. That’s why it’s best practice to use these suppliers, even if in a limited capacity — sourcing 10% of a material from them and 90% from less expensive sources — so you can call them into action quickly.

Demand planning: While demand planning isn’t technically part of supply chain practices, it does need to inform resilience discussions. Unless leaders understand how not receiving materials from a certain supplier will affect production, they won’t know how critical it is to line up on-call backups.

Demand planning means having a clear picture of the link between raw materials and products. How would a missed purchase order from Supplier A affect your overall product catalog? Supply chain managers can then review production plans, compare that against expected demand and adjust accordingly.

And there are other factors here. Every company needs to know what its top-performing 20% of SKUs are, which have the highest profit margins and which are quickest to sell through. That information is invaluable if you need to modify production schedules due to raw-material shortages or semi-functional manufacturing floors. It allows you to prioritize manufacturing of these products and ensure you're not using limited raw materials to produce products that deliver the lowest margins or that might end up sitting in a warehouse. For future planning, remember to mark times of disruption as outliers so they can be excluded.

4. Manufacturing: Business leaders need a plan for meeting demand when production teams and/or facilities cannot operate at full capacity. Say you are implementing social distancing and need to turn to subcontracting or additional shifts just to fill existing orders. Should you turn to subcontractors or temporary workers? If that’s a logical solution, subcontractors and temp agencies should be preapproved. In the immediate wake of a disruption is no time to be checking references. If a facility cannot produce at normal levels, are there third-party contract manufacturers that could take over for a limited period, and how does that impact your bottom line?

On the other end of the spectrum, it’s smart to have a similar plan for a sudden, unforeseen increase in demand (hello, toilet paper). Companies may need to take advantage of the same resources if this happens, in addition to, instead of in place of, current facilities and employees. Flexibility and creativity are essential in adapting to either situation.

5. Inventory management: You need accurate, up-to-date visibility into current inventory, including both finished and unfinished goods, to respond properly to unexpected changes in your supply chain. By looking at available inventory, expected demand and incoming orders, a company can make informed decisions and prioritize appropriately. Do you have enough inventory on-hand to keep selling for a month or so? Or is there limited supply that requires turning to those backup manufacturers right away?

As a safeguard, you could build up inventory reserves of essential materials for popular products so you’re not immediately scrambling after a disruption. This is an upfront investment and could incur storage costs but offers valuable leeway during challenging moments.

Note: Inventory management is a key piece of the supply chain puzzle. If you find you have excess inventory of the wrong products eating up space and cash, it’s a good time to coordinate with sales and marketing to run promotions to move it out.

6. Warehousing: Your business may need to temporarily house inventory at another location for a number of reasons. A warehouse could become unusable because of a flood or broken equipment, for example. Production could increase due to surging demand, or there could be excess inventory of certain products where demand has slowed.

Outsourcing typically makes the most sense when creating a contingency plan for warehousing, often with a third-party logistics (3PL) provider. While a 3PL may be more expensive than a business warehousing its own products, it’s a fast and relatively simple solution. After moving inventory to a 3PL site, a company could set it up as an additional location to maintain visibility into inventory and control over what is received, shipped or assembled there.

7. Customer Service: When orders are delayed or can’t be fulfilled due to a supply chain disruption, maintain a clear line of communication with customers: What’s causing the problem, what you’re doing to resolve the situation and best estimates of how it all affects timelines. Even though customers may be frustrated, transparency and prompt communication will help build long-term satisfaction and loyalty.

A contingency plan should include a clear message for all customer service personnel and sales reps to share with customers who want updates on the status of their orders or have questions. The message should be clear, honest and timely.

Example of Supply Chain Resilience: Alton Lane

The coronavirus outbreak impacted men’s apparel brand Alton Lane well before it began spreading rapidly in the United States. Alton Lane sources fabric for its custom suits, shirts and pants from England, Portugal and Belgium. That fabric is sent to tailors in Western Europe and Asia, who turn it into the brand’s clothing and accessories.

When the coronavirus reached Italy, the fabric mills Alton Lane uses in that country shut down for a few weeks, breaking a key link in its supply chain. However, the redundancy the Virginia-based retailer built into its supply chain prevented this from being a crippling event.

Training & Education for Suppliers, Supply Chain Pros

There are a number of certifications that companies looking to up their supply chain games can look for. Here are five of the most popular.

Issuer: Association for Supply Chain Management

Issuer: Institute for Supply Management

  • Certified Professional in Supply Management (CPSM) addresses the realities of supply management, as well as workplace complexities including globalization, use of technology, and expanded competencies that procurement and supply chain professionals employ to drive value in their organizations.
  • ISM Certified Professional in Supplier Diversity (CPSD) provides knowledge and training to show an organization how supplier diversity can improve the bottom line and accelerate innovation by becoming more efficient and by getting exposure to new customer bases.

“This is something that I think was important to us early on — clearly never would’ve expected a global pandemic — but we always try to protect against geopolitical risk,” CEO and co-founder Colin Hunter said. “So we have redundancy in our supply chain, both on the fabric side and the factory side, across multiple countries.”

Hunter credits that insight to an experience early in the company’s history.

“Our first factory was in Thailand and I remember there were riots in Thailand at the time,” he said. “And it’s like, ‘Gosh, we have one factory, what happens if we lose it? We’re toast.’”

Alton Lane was able to quickly reroute orders. It has factories in Spain, Portugal, Germany, Thailand and Vietnam, and it helped that certain Italian mills had fabric stored at a distribution center in Hong Kong. The retailer has continued to make almost every product it sells, with the exception of belts, as just one factory manufactured those.

This supply chain resilience paid off in another way. Alton Lane faced a dip in sales as it temporarily closed all 12 of its showrooms, where it does most of its fittings and business. But as it redirected orders, certain partners gave the brand breaks in exchange for receiving a larger book of business.

“On the fabric side, we’re able to shift volume to this factory in this time because of certain closures, but what can you do for us in terms of pricing now or in terms of credit terms?” Hunter said.

Mitigating and Monitoring Risk

Responding appropriately to a supply chain disruption requires constant monitoring.

By building a resilience plan and then using it to make necessary adjustments to your supply chain, your company identified potential risks. Now, you need a plan to develop an “early warning signal” so you can spot threats as promptly as possible and activate plans before competitors are also searching for backup suppliers.

Once you’ve mitigated potential negative effects by taking proactive measures, continue to follow the disruptive event as it evolves, and modify your response accordingly.

Terms To Know, Resources To Use

Resilience triangle:The resilience triangle“is a tool developed in the field of civil engineering, with the objective of modeling the loss of resilience of a given structure during and after the occurrence of a disruption such as an earthquake.” In the context of a supply chain, companies can use the tool to visualize potential impacts of disruptions.

Company resilience index: Issued by property insurer FM Global, the free 2020 Resilience Index provides insights on nearly 130 countries to help evaluate regions, site business operations, select partners and make more informed strategic choices.

Resistance Capacity & Recovery Capacity: In a seminal paper on supply chain resilience, experts posit that “resilience happens by design and not by accident. The resilient supply chain requires two critical capacities: the capacity for resistance and the capacity for recovery. The first, resistance, defines the supply chain’s ability to delay a disruption and reduce the impact once the disruption occurs. The second, recovery, defines the supply chain’s ability to recover from a disruption.”

For example, as recently as February, the coronavirus seemed like a distant concern for most American business owners. But those who monitored the situation closely saw U.S. cases steadily growing and could foresee it becoming a substantial problem. They could then start preparing for supply chain disruption.

As you emerge from a disruption, whether the coronavirus or something less dramatic, do a post-mortem analysis of how the supply chain held up, and look for ways to add value in the future. A few things to consider:

  • Is supplier distribution optimized, or are you relying too heavily on some partners?
  • What pieces of your supply chain are onshore vs. offshore, from raw material providers to manufacturers to warehousing and distribution partners? Is it the right mix?
  • Are there any areas of the supply chain that are currently standalone but that could be centralized or integrated?
  • Are there any areas of the supply chain that seem redundant and could be consolidated?
  • Did your contingency plan work the way you thought it would? What could you improve before the next disruption arrives?

Investing in Supply Chain Resilience

There are additional costs, at least initially, that come with building supply chain resilience. Mapping your supply chain, finding backup suppliers and other partners and pulling in demand planning and other functions requires significant human and capital resources.

However, as has hopefully become clear, your company could recover those expenses in weeks, if not days, if there is a major supply chain disruption. Just the ability to shift operations on the fly to other partners, with minimal interruption to top SKUs, could save thousands or even millions of dollars, depending on the nature of the disruption and size of your organization.

It is a necessary investment for any product-based business, even more so for those with complex global supply chains.

While supply chain disruptions can’t be avoided, businesses that can address them proactively, following a thoughtful contingency plan, will minimize disruption. Not only will that help the company’s bottom line, it should ensure a better customer experience.

For more insights, read the three-step guide to Managing Business Uncertainty.

Abby Jenkins is a product marketing manager at NetSuite covering supply chain, inventory, warehouse and order management. Prior to joining NetSuite, Abby worked in new product development for branded manufacturers, including American Crew and Hunter Douglas.

Ian McCue is a content manager at NetSuite who also contributes to Grow Wire and the NetSuite blog. A former sports writer, he previously wrote about supply chain challenges and technology at HighJump Software. Reach Ian here.

Mark Bianco

For more helpful information from the Brainyard and our friends at Grow Wire and the NetSuite Blog, visit the Business Now Resource Guide.

  

Sales Chat

How is your business adapting to change?

Start chat